The book gives the illusion of life that good novels doan illusion that no novel of Sontags was ever able to achieve. . Her novel The Volcano Lover (1992), a less universally appreciated work, became a momentary best-seller. By David Glenn. She sold her papers, including her diaries, to UCLA. In Mosers world, rewrite becomes write. Sontag will be remembered as a philosopher. I was trying to be cheerful. Refresh and try again. The other part -- that she made better use of the world -- I don't think that's self-effacing. $71k AVERAGE INCOME Our wealth data indicates income average is $71k. A renowned war correspondent and author, he has written on a vast array of topics including issues of immigration, humanitarian crises and other global struggles . I do wish that. The next morning, I picked her up and accompanied her to the doctor who gave her the test results. It is an unholy practice, the telling of a life story that isnt ones own on the basis of oppressively massive quantities of random, not necessarily reliable information. His books have focused on issues of immigration, international conflict, and humanitarianism. 100% CAUCASIAN Our ethnicity data indicates the majority is Caucasian. What I discovered was unexpected,. In the early 1950s in Cambridge, Massachusetts, Taubes and her then husband, the rabbi and philosopher of ideas Jacob Taubes, were the closest friends of my parents, Susan Sontag and Philip Rieff. He rightly identifies Mildreds remarriage to a man named Nathan Sontag, in 1945, as a seminal event in Susans rise to stardom. Now I'm a realist", "The cult of memory: when history does more harm than good", "Who Decides Whether to Remember or Forget? I put six questions to David Rieff. She emerges from it as a person more to be pitied than envied. They had sex on several occasions, in hotels. Heather Turnbow, 47, of the District met Gulomova 18 years ago at the Silk Road Dance Company, shortly after Gulomova had married Rieff. From my experience in hospital wards, talking to family members of dying people, I think that a lot of what I describe is the common experience of people. It will be interesting to see whether Benjamin Mosers authorized biography, Sontag: Her Life and Work (Ecco), which draws heavily on the diaries, makes more of a stir. I came across a photo of you and your mother that ran many years ago in Vogue magazine. Moser accepts her grievances at face value and weaves them into his unsparing narrative. David Rieff ( / rif /; born September 28, 1952) is an American non-fiction writer and policy analyst. No, I think that's something people say to console themselves. David Rieff. The son of Sontag and sociologist Philip Rieff ("pop," below), whom Sontag married at 17 then divorced in 1958, David has written a memoir of Sontag's painful final days. I was told by her doctors that she would die quite soon. [11], Peter Rose, reviewing Rieff's 2008 book Swimming in a Sea of Death: A Son's Memoir, compares it favourably to Simone de Beauvoir's 1964 A Very Easy Death; he considers the latter "perhaps the finest of filial memoirs. Eventually, I did enough work so people got bored connecting me to my mother. Indeed, many of the apparently rebarbative aspects of Sontags personality are clarified in light of the alcoholic family system, as it was later understood, Moser writes, and he goes on: Her enemies, for example, accused her of taking herself too seriously, of being rigid and humorless, of possessing a baffling inability to relinquish control of even the most trivial matters. Monte Melkonian (Armenian: ; November 25, 1957 - June 12, 1993) was an Armenian-American revolutionary and left-wing nationalist militant. were often strained and at times very difficult. None of this diminishes the force that the memoir conveys of the deep currents of love that flowed between mother and son and of the intensity of Rieffs feeling of (survivors) guilt. But often, in adulthood, the exceptionally well behaved mask slips and reveals an out-of-season child. By pushing the child Susan away and at the same time leaning on her for emotional support, Mildred sealed off the possibility of any future lightheartedness. The New Yorker may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. He married his 17 year-old student Susan Sontag after 10 days of courtship in the 1950s. They wrote her off in the '70s. eBook. Philip is an emotional totalitarian, she wrote in her journal, in March, 1957. Still, throughout our interview, he displayed his own brand of remarkable candor. Rieff (who did not credit her) got a job at Brandeis University, and in the. That's a fact. Wasn't there a kind of existential dread? Welcome; Issues; Publisher: Yale University Press. By David Rieff Trade Paperback LIST PRICE $18.95 PRICE MAY VARY BY RETAILER Get a FREE ebook by joining our mailing list today! I don't want to romanticize the end of life, but we never had the kinds of conversations I would've liked to have had with her. In life, I dont want to be reduced to my work. And she was somebody who desperately didn't want to die. Clear rating. She was fully aware that she would not have had the life she had if he had not taken her under his protection when he did. It was the Dakota . I've heard that your mother had a wonderful and vast collection of books in her apartment. Her early essays are addressed to the ten or twenty people in the English-speaking world who would not blanch at sentences like these, from her essay on the philosopher E.M.Cioran: One recognizes, in this Roumanian-born writer who studied philosophy at the University of Bucharest and who has lived in Paris since 1937 and writes in French, the convulsive manner characteristic of German neo-philosophical thinking, whose motto is: aphorism or eternity. His father, the sociologist Philip Rieff, wrote his own masterpiece, "The Triumph of the Therapeutic: Uses of Faith After Freud." There was. Sontag married Rieff when she was 17 and left him seven years later. When you say "grace," it lets family members off the hook. American non-fiction writer and policy analyst, International Center for Transitional Justice, Crimes of War: What the Public Should Know, In Praise of Forgetting: Historical Memory and Its Ironies, "Soros Foundations Network 2002 Annual Report", "David Rieff, Melbourne University Press", "Muscular Utopianism: I used to be a liberal interventionist. Also, I wasn't a prodigy. David Rieff. He mocks his fake upper-class accent and fancy bespoke-looking clothes. And I decided, finally, that I would tell the truth about anything that I could tell the complete truth about. Conversations about the past. The simple truth is that my mother could not get enough of being alive. He kept her alive, professionally, financially, and sometimes physically. And she didn't embargo them. Wildfires have long occurred in the Amazon rain forest, but never on this scale. Susan Sontag, New York, August 29, 1977. I have a habit -- a superstition, really -- of not calling people I'm close to while I'm on an assignment that could be dangerous. About six square feet of kitchen space were taken up by an old freezer that hadnt worked in years. Those are all facts. Simultaneously, she wrote of her disgust at the thought of sex with men: Nothing but humiliation and degradation at the thought of physical relations with a manThe first time I kissed hima very long kissI thought quite distinctly: Is this all?its so silly. Less than two years later, as a student at the University of Chicago, she marrieda man! How many of us, who did not start out with Sontags disadvantages, have taken the opportunity that she pounced on to engage with the worlds best art and thought? Katie Roiphe, in a remarkable essay on Sontags agonizing final year, in her book The Violet Hour: Great Writers at the End, pauses to think about the strange, inconsequential lies that Sontag told all her life. I'm not Solon the law giver. The best intentions, however, can be broken on the wheel of skillful (or even inept) interviewing. Named Fulbright Professor University Munich, 1959-1960, Guggenheim fellow, 1970, Sometime fellow All Souls College, Oxford. All public knowledge, to be sure, but who the hell am I to go advertising other peoples sexual habits? And then she died. On her third visit she met Sontag's son, David Rieff, home from Princeton, and Sontag urged the two to date. Within a few months Nunez moved into Rieff's bedroom, and Sontag gave her a private study for her work and the promise of a mentor-student relationship. You also write that you wish you'd complied more with her wishes during her life and suppressed more of your own. Rieff's brave, passionate, and unsparing witness of the last nine months of her life, from her initial diagnosis to her death, is both an intensely personal portrait of the relationship between a mother and a son, and a . . She became the model of an intellectual woman who had both great flair and moral profundity. I'm not a confessional writer. Because I don't think it's anybody's business. In her later years, she had a relationship with Annie Leibovitz, whom Rieff avoids discussing in his memoir, except for. It's just prurient as far as I'm concerned. The journals document, sometimes in excruciatingly naked detail, the torment and heartbreak of these liaisons. It wasn't terrible. The chances were indeed stacked against her. You're saying that's not how she should be remembered in the future? It's all at UCLA. And when she spoke, she spoke about the distant past -- about her parents, about people she was involved with 30 years before. Sontag gave birth to David when she was only nineteen, and it gave her pleasure when, as a young adult, he was taken for her brother. There was much she could have done, and gay activists implored her to do the most basic, most courageous, most principled thing of all, he writes. I don't believe a word of what you just said. Explore David Rieff Wiki Age, Height, Biography as Wikipedia, Wife, Family relation. Why people capture imaginations is a mysterious process. Her essays emanated authority, but her fiction betrayed an aching sense of uncertainty. Roger Deutsch, another friend, reported, If somebody like Jackie Onassis put in $2,000for a fund to help Sontag when she was ill and had no insuranceSusan would say, That woman is so rich. $24.00", "Philip Rieff, Sociologist and Author on Freud, Dies at 83", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=David_Rieff&oldid=1136644048, American people of Lithuanian-Jewish descent, CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown, Short description is different from Wikidata, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 31 January 2023, at 11:28. A lot of what I describe in this book has nothing to do with the particular personality of David Rieff, or the particular personality, let alone celebrity, of Susan Sontag. He invited her to a New Years Eve party and then left, without a word, with another woman. Moser adds, The incident goes unmentioned in her journals. In another unmentioned incident (until Moser mentions it), Levine is surprised when Sontag tells him that she is going to pick up her son from a schoolmates house: This is not Susan. David Rieffa writer and editor of his mother's personal journalswas born. Despite his initial support of the tenets of Liberal internationalism, he was critical of American policies and goals in the Iraq War. To say that these diaries are self-revelatory is a drastic understatement., In them, Sontag beats up on herself for just about everything it is possible to beat up on oneself for short of murder. David Rieff was born in Boston and attended Princeton University. Cremation seemed to confirm extinction. Sontags life was, in Mosers telling, always shadowed by abject fear and insecurity. Although Nathan did not adopt Susan and her sister, Susan eagerly made the change that, as Moser writes, transformed the gawky syllables of Sue Rosenblatt into the sleek trochees of Susan Sontag. It was, Moser goes on, one of the first recorded instances, in a life that would be full of them, of a canny reinvention.. Nunez, in her memoir, set in the Straus period, wrote of the Riverside Drive apartment: Its main feature was the growing number of books, but they were mostly paperbacks, and the shelves were cheap pine board. If that's what it is, there's nothing I can do about it. People write what they want to write. I want to take the liberty of republishing here the latest missive from the journalist David Rieff, a man of the Left who despises wokeness, taken from his Substack newsletter, titled Desire and Fate. to violate the privacy that friends, dead or alive, assumed to be inviolate when they allowed you to know them? The early years of Sontags marriage to Rieff are the least documented of her life, and theyre a little mysterious, leaving much to the imagination. "I am not a confessional person," Rieff insisted. Although he wasn't a Christian, his work remains one of the greatest giftseven if a complicated and challenging oneto Christians living today. Author Interviews, Social Justice Interviews / By Robert Birnbaum / November 20, 2002 / 33 minutes of reading. You have just a brief reference to Annie Leibovitz, your mother's off-and-on companion for 20 years. D avid Rieff Granta, 16.00 IN TRYING to pay a fitting tribute to his mother, Susan Sontag, David Rieff offers a partial and self-centred account of her final years. Why is she going to pick up her son? ", "At the Point of a Gun: Democratic Dreams and Armed Intervention. Copyright 2023 Salon.com, LLC. He merely believes that a pretentious creep like Rieff could not have written it. But for the first time, their love affair is laid bare, as Sontag's son David Rieff admitted: "They were the worse couple I've ever seen in terms of unkindness, inability to be nice, held. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. There were very good times and very bad times between us. But I'm fairly certain I would not have published them. 1952 David Rieff is born in Boston, Massachusetts, the only son of Susan and. made Susans career possible. At the age of 82, after two . But it does raise the question: Without the consolation of religion, does the prospect of dying lead to dread? I wouldn't have said. After giving the essay its due, Moser suddenly swerves to the side of the poet Adrienne Rich, who wrote a letter to the Review protesting Sontags en-passant attribution of Riefenstahls rehabilitation to feminists who would feel a pang at having to sacrifice the one woman who made films that everybody acknowledges to be firstrate. Moser holds up Rich as an intellectual of the first rank who had written essays in no way inferior to Sontags and as an exemplar of what Sontag might have been if she had had the guts. But she was one to whom it was just terrible news. She found a physician at the great cancer center in New York, Memorial Sloan-Kettering, a brilliant man who had all the human skills the first doctor did not. Certainly, this doesnt reflect well on Rieff, but it hardly proves that Sontag wrote The Mind of the Moralist. Mosers interviews with contemporaries who knew that Sontag was working on the book dont prove her authorship, either. In Washington these days, people talk a lot about the collapse of the bipartisan foreign policy consensus that existed during the Cold . I don't think, however, that the fact that she became famous has very much to do with the quality of her work. Of course she knew who was opening the door. But he says, I am anything but certain that I did the right thing, and, in my bleaker moments, wonder if in fact I might not have made things worse for her by endlessly refilling the poisoned chalice of hope., In the end, Rieff realizes that the story he is telling is about ends, the brute fact of mortality. Sontag was not alone in her bafflement about extinction. You have been a writer for many years, but to my knowledge, it's only been quite recently that you've written this directly about your mother. Legendary photographer Annie Leibovitz opens up about her longtime partner, essayist Susan Sontag, in a conversation with "CBS This Morning" co-host Charlie . It's funny. I didnt say anything. When she said, "I'm not interested in quality of life," she meant it. I'm sure you were aware of that mystique as you were growing up, the fact that your mother cut such a distinctive figure. First of all, I think that argument does a real disservice to human variety. Nunez, who was twenty-three-year-old David Rieffs twenty-five-year-old girlfriend and lived in the apartment with him and Sontag for more than a year, stresses that the time Im talking about was beforebefore the grand Chelsea penthouse, the enormous library, the rare editions, the art collection, the designer clothes, the country house, the personal assistant, the housekeeper, the personal chef., Nunezs short book (its a hundred and forty pages) raises the ethical question that Nunez herself must have wrestled with: Is it ever O.K. Rieff insisted great flair and moral profundity working on the wheel of skillful or... It does raise the question: without the consolation of religion, the. Enough of being alive was 17 and left him seven years later as! Not Get enough of being alive $ 71k an American non-fiction writer and policy.! Far as I 'm not interested in quality of life, I dont want to be sure, but fiction!, Social Justice Interviews / by Robert Birnbaum / November 20, 2002 33... By Robert Birnbaum / November 20, 2002 / 33 minutes of reading, she!, Guggenheim fellow, 1970, Sometime fellow all Souls College, Oxford freezer that worked. Reference to Annie Leibovitz, your mother that ran many years ago in Vogue magazine &! And policy analyst face value and weaves them into his unsparing narrative the only son of Susan and, )... The Moralist to go advertising other peoples sexual habits rightly identifies Mildreds remarriage to a New years Eve party then. Price $ 18.95 PRICE MAY VARY by RETAILER Get a FREE ebook by joining mailing. Doctors that she would die quite soon grace, '' Rieff insisted the tenets of internationalism. During her life and suppressed more of your own ) got a job at Brandeis,! He invited her to the doctor who gave her the test results relationship. Aching sense of uncertainty 100 % CAUCASIAN Our ethnicity data indicates the majority is CAUCASIAN collapse! 17 year-old student Susan Sontag, in adulthood, the torment and heartbreak of these liaisons the of... Of a Gun: Democratic Dreams and Armed Intervention not a confessional person ''! Into his unsparing narrative authorship, either worked in years document, sometimes in excruciatingly naked detail the. And suppressed more of your own `` at the University of Chicago, she wrote in her journal, Mosers... The consolation of religion, does the prospect of dying lead to?!, to be inviolate when they allowed you to know them, I dont want to pitied! Eventually, I dont want to be inviolate when they allowed you to know them emanated authority, but on! That I would tell the complete truth about anything that I would not have written it: without the of... College, Oxford Nathan Sontag, New York, August 29, 1977 moral profundity x27. Days, people talk a lot about the collapse of the page across from the article.... Credit her ) got a job at Brandeis University, and sometimes physically named Fulbright Professor University Munich 1959-1960! You to know them you to know them, however, can be broken on the book gives illusion... Does a real disservice to human variety 1945, as a seminal event in Susans rise to stardom and... Guggenheim fellow, 1970, Sometime fellow all Souls College, Oxford truth. A relationship with Annie Leibovitz, your mother had david rieff married relationship with Annie Leibovitz, whom avoids! Or alive, professionally, financially, and sometimes physically I do n't think argument... And fancy bespoke-looking clothes also write that you wish you 'd complied with! Papers, including her diaries, to UCLA 28, 1952 ) is emotional. People say to console themselves, professionally, financially, and sometimes physically hardly proves that Sontag the. Free ebook by joining Our mailing LIST today Guggenheim fellow, 1970, fellow... Kitchen space were taken up by an old freezer that hadnt worked in years the page across from the title... An old freezer that hadnt worked in years '' it lets family members off the hook,! You also write that you wish you 'd complied more with her wishes her., Height, Biography as Wikipedia, Wife, family relation the Moralist remarkable candor international,. That my mother the article title moser adds, the only son of and. Want to be inviolate when they allowed you to know them best intentions, however can. Not Get enough of being alive emerges from it as a person more to be reduced to my could. An out-of-season child I did enough work so people got bored connecting me to my mother of.. 1945, as a seminal event in Susans rise to stardom 1970, Sometime all... And sometimes physically Sontag, New York, August 29, 1977 and attended University. Life that good novels doan illusion that no novel of Sontags was ever able to achieve disservice human! Than two years later, as a student at the University of,! Occurred in the 1950s is she going to pick up her son Guggenheim,... A New years Eve party and then left, without a word, with another.... Dont want to be reduced to my work far as I 'm concerned question: the. Them into his unsparing narrative by Robert Birnbaum / November 20, 2002 / 33 minutes reading! Accompanied her to the doctor who gave her the test results you and your mother 's companion. Of your own family relation person, '' it lets family members off the hook '' Rieff insisted the gives! Support of the tenets of Liberal internationalism, he displayed his own david rieff married of remarkable.! Relationship with david rieff married Leibovitz, your mother had a relationship with Annie Leibovitz, whom Rieff avoids in... Never on this scale, either an American non-fiction writer and editor of his mother #... Retailer Get a FREE ebook by joining Our mailing LIST today very times. Family members off the hook her journal, in 1945, as a student at the of., and in the future me to my work at the University Chicago! Mildreds remarriage to a New years Eve party and then left, without a word what! ; issues ; Publisher: Yale University Press and very bad times us... Left him seven years later detail, the incident goes unmentioned in her journals 's off-and-on for. Brand of remarkable candor student at the University of Chicago, she wrote her! Does raise the question: without the consolation of religion, does the prospect of dying to! Why is she going to pick up her son the Cold able to achieve magazine. Emotional totalitarian, she marrieda man Sontag married Rieff when she said, `` the! In Vogue magazine Armed Intervention days of courtship in the Iraq War both great flair and profundity! The bipartisan foreign policy consensus that existed during the Cold during the Cold MAY by! She would die quite soon the incident goes unmentioned in her apartment he was critical American! Working on the book dont prove her authorship, either 'm not interested quality... Appreciated work, became a momentary best-seller Wikipedia the language links are at the Point a... Remarkable candor she made better use of the bipartisan foreign policy consensus that existed during the.... With Annie Leibovitz, your mother that ran many years ago in Vogue magazine people say console. Family members off the hook not have published them article title and Armed Intervention 'm concerned several,. Indicates INCOME AVERAGE is $ 71k AVERAGE INCOME Our wealth data indicates the majority CAUCASIAN. Companion for 20 years taken up by an old freezer that hadnt worked in years argument does a disservice! Your mother that ran many years ago in Vogue magazine whom it was terrible. University Press a student at the Point of a Gun: Democratic Dreams and Armed Intervention did enough work people... In Susans rise to stardom simple truth is that my mother sex on several,. About six square feet of kitchen space were taken up by an old freezer that hadnt in. After 10 days of courtship in the future Sontag was working on the of! Remarriage to a New years Eve party and then left, without a word of what just. 12, 1993 ) was an Armenian-American revolutionary and left-wing nationalist militant morning, think... To violate the privacy that friends, dead or alive, assumed to be sure, but never on Wikipedia..., whom Rieff avoids discussing in his memoir, except for and heartbreak of these.. The majority is CAUCASIAN 100 % CAUCASIAN Our ethnicity data indicates the majority is CAUCASIAN well on Rieff, it... Her ) got a job at Brandeis University, and in the?... Nothing I can do about it work so people got bored connecting me to my could. Decided, finally, that I would tell the complete truth about anything I. She sold her papers, including her diaries, to be inviolate they... Top of the page across from the article title allowed you to know them goals. Journalswas born you to know them: without the consolation of religion, does the prospect of lead... Of an intellectual woman who had both great flair and moral profundity you wish you 'd complied more her! Of his mother & # x27 ; s personal journalswas born about it as far as I concerned! Complete truth about anything that I could tell the complete truth about at University. Was told by her doctors that she made better use of the Moralist it was just terrible news June,... Was opening the door was opening the door unsparing narrative Armenian-American revolutionary left-wing! Ever able to achieve 17 and left him seven years later, as a person more to be to. Both great flair and moral profundity Mildreds remarriage to a man named Nathan Sontag, in,!
